Fool me once, shame on you.
Fool me twice, shame on me…or rather on the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors who have sent a letter to California’s Secretary of Agriculture, A.G. Kawamura, begging him to hurry up and help them douse the county in poison and pesticides as the latest step in the Light Brown Apple Moth scandal.
Remember A.G. Kawamura? He works for the CDFA who did this to little children in Santa Cruz and Monterey Counties in the fall of 2007:

Remember how the CDFA wanted to spray all the way up to the SF Bay Area and everywhere in between in 2008:

Remember how in May 2009, the EPA banned the Checkmate Pesticides CDFA had already sprayed on Central California families and wanted to spray on all Californians everywhere?

Remember how this banning finally took place after the EPA, the OEHHA, the USDA, the CDFA and Gov. Schwarzenegger repeatedly assured Californians of the total safety of spraying pesticides on men, women and children…all the while suggesting that we go inside our houses while the spraying happened?
Yes, you remember and I remember how Californians were terrorized, abused and lied to by the CDFA and its willing and greedy cohorts in the name of agribusiness being given hundreds of millions of dollars in funding for their utterly unfounded, ludicrous and deadly LBAM ‘eradication’ effort.
But the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors doesn’t remember. The California Certified Organic Farmers association doesn’t remember. The California Native Plant Society doesn’t remember. The California Land Stewardship Institute doesn’t remember. The Occidental Arts and Ecology Center doesn’t remember.
In their state of what I can only describe as hysterical amnesia, they have all decided that the CDFA is right. The CDFA is trustworthy. The CDFA is honest and good…and the light brown apple moth is a horrendous threat to all living things. Yes, the CDFA who poured deadly, now-banned pesticides over family homes while infants were rushed off to ERs in 2007 is the group of folks these organizations have decided to turn to as the authors of truth about the light brown apple moth.
As this cowardly, cringing Sonoma Board letter demonstrates, all of those who signed it have decided to jump on the LBAM charade bandwagon, casting aside all science, all ethics, all reason in order to be relieved of the burden of the totally phony quarantines that have been imposed as blackmail upon the region by the CDFA. They have played directly into the hands of A.G. Kawamura and the pesticide manufacturers and have acted without one modicum of backbone.
Rather than protect their own children from the utterly toxic poisons of pesticide twist ties, BTK, spinosad and other pesticides, these organizations have invited CDFA’s ghouls to ride into town, set up the most expensive possible ‘eradication’ program they can dream up and get on with the spraying. No, the LBAM still hasn’t done any damage to anything despite 3 years of being under microscopic scrutiny in the state and despite the fact that it has lived here for 50+ years. No, there are no grounds for panic or hysteria. No need to protect yourself or your plants from this infinitesimal insect. The moth harms nothing…whereas the twist ties and sprays are utterly toxic to all of us. Yet, these organizations are saying, ‘spray our kids and save us from…a bug.’
It’s disgusting. It’s completely disgusting what CDFA has done to the people of California and it’s agonizing to watch the organizations get in line to ask for another whipping, and fast. How any of the people who supported that letter can live with themselves knowing that they are joining league with a government agency that put children in the hospital in Santa Cruz and Monterey in 2007, I simply don’t know.
It isn’t that the Board, the California Certified Organic Farmers association and other groups don’t know better. It’s that they’ve chosen to drown out their consciences in order to get with the program, even if that means pretending to believe in total lies about a totally harmless insect and causing harm to their own families. It has become easier for these people to get with the program than to get real about what agribusiness is doing to California, the US and the world. These people must not be ready to get real and say ‘no’ to the devastation to life being caused by agribusiness around the globe. It’s horrific to have them not ready, and yet sitting on boards and signing their names to documents of ignorance and shame.
The Truth Is
The truth is that the Napa-Sonoma region is already so drowned in carcinogenic pesticides because of the industrial production of alcohol that it’s amazing anything is left alive there. If a couple of light brown apple moths are managing to gasp for breath amidst the nightly pesticide spraying that takes place across Napa, Sonoma, Kenwood, St. Helena, Calistoga and Cloverdale 8 months out of every year, I’m actually amazed. Everyone who lives in the Napa-Sonoma region wonders where the butterflies, the birds and frogs have gone, and because the spraying is done nightly under the cloak of darkness, few residents ever connect the alcohol industry to the loss of the rich biodiversity that was once ours.
It is absolutely no surprise to see all of the alcohol growers eagerly signing their names to anything that will lift the quarantines on their toxic liquor products. These people are in the pesticide business. They’ve got scores of migrant workers riding the spray machines for them night after night. They couldn’t care less about a few more tons of pesticides being added to the unfathomable load they are already dumping in the wasteland they market as ‘The Wine Country’.
But, the funny thing is, the alcohol industry CEOs like to do things under the cover of darkness. It keeps the public from seeing that their migrant workers aren’t even wearing masks and it keeps you from connecting the dots about their toxic business practices and your ruined health, your polluted town and your collapsing local environment.
In this case, however, with this letter, there are the names of their associations in black-and-white for anyone who happens to see that document to read. They are publicly endorsing the use of pesticides where you live, including if they have to bust down your gate to get into your backyard as these interests have been doing to our elders in Ojai, California. This time, what’s happening isn’t after midnight on those silent summer evenings in the alcohol valleys. This time, they are showing their hand and this gives you a chance to learn the truth about the presence of industrial alcohol production in California, the ethics of its proponents and its direct effects on you.
You can already see the utter fools being made of your neighbors by the games agribusiness plays within communities. To see the California Certified Organic Farmers endorsing constitution-crippling pesticide practices pretty much says it all to me. CDFA and the alcohol growers have managed to confuse and manipulate the state in a manner humanitarians would deem diabolical and I have to remind myself to have pity for those people on the various boards who are acting out of that abused mindset. I don’t hate those board members. I am completely pained by what has to be either their ignorance, or their corruption and I am just shaking my head over what is happening here in California.
We’re dead broke, we’re closing all of the state parks that support mental health by offering opportunities for exercise and contact with the natural world, and simultaneously, we’re begging government organizations to fill our towns with mood-altering pesticides that can result in psychosis. To me, the possible outcomes of this twisted combination of dangerous factors is no joking matter. It’s deadly serious.
What do you think?



15 users commented in " LBAM Update: Sonoma Board and Assoc. Hysterical Over Nothing "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackWow, what an article. It is so rare that the pure truth is delivered in such an eloquent fashion. The signers of that Sonoma sell-out letter must have their personal rationalizations that they cling to, but Vegan Reader has clearly identified there are no valid compromises involving crimes against children.
Maybe now the signers will reconsider. It’s never too late to do the right thing.
Welcome, Robert,
And thank you so much for your praise of this article. We are sincerely disturbed by the Sonoma Board letter and find it so hard to believe that Californians could have already found it convenient to forget who they’re doing business with when they are doing business with the CDFA.
Your final point is so right! It’s never too late to do the right thing. We’re praying people will remember that.
Thank you so much for taking the time to comment.
Mim
i think i am glad you covered this. that letter gave me shivers and i am worried about the health of people i love in sonoma county. i actually visited sonoma county as a place to escape the lbam spray! it was the first time i reacted to the usual pesticide spraying that goes on there and i felt very sad that i can never return to a place i considered home. my poetry professor from sonoma state just passed away and i am afraid to go up there to him memorial.
Hi Donna,
A couple of days ago, Sonoma County had a heavy cloud cover. You know how stuffy that makes things. People I spoke to were having trouble breathing in that, and all I could think of was the massive amount of ‘spring’ pesticides being trapped between the clouds and the Earth. It was really upsetting to think about, and I am so sorry that reading the letter and article disturbed you so.
We need to remember that our shivers and fears are the right reaction to this. They are common sense alerting us to danger so that we can try to find a way to survive. This is becoming increasingly difficult because of the increasing use of pesticides and herbicides. We must suffer the unpleasantness and fear in order to confront the problem, learn about it and address it. You and I are part of the solution.
I am so sorry you are unable to attend the funeral of your valued teacher. That is extremely sad, Donna. Hang in there, and thank you for taking the time to comment. It is always good to see you here.
Mim
hi mim
has the spraying season begun? i posted this article to the sos list and forwarded it to my friend in santa rosa.
i hope there is clean air where you live and that you don’t get hit too hard when you have to go into town.
unless they reclassify the moth or something happens that stops this program i’m leaving calif. in sept. seems crazy still! because it is……..
donna
isnt it odd that people are under the impression that fewer chemicals are being used, due to disapproval of them in general and a consumer trend to want “natural” things, while, hidden in the disguise of glorious wine country lore, this horrid truth exists?
Hi Donna,
In our personal experience, the spraying of vineyards happens from about March through October…8 months out of each year, and each vineyard is sprayed between 4-8 nights each of these months. Basically, what this boils down to is that if you live in the ‘Wine Country’, pesticides, herbicides and fungicides are being sprayed in some vineyard near your home every night for 3/4 of every year. It’s massive, chronic exposure to carcinogens and mutagens for every resident that goes on year after year.
So, the spraying has definitely begun. You can really smell it along the portion of HWY 12 that runs from Santa Rosa to Sonoma and we are thankful every day that we no longer live there. The few times we have had to go back, our family felt totally sick from being re-exposed to the toxins.
All, I can say is…if you buy wine, please buy Organic wine.
I am totally distressed that you feel you will be forced to move in September if the LBAM program isn’t stopped, Donna. We also researched this option, but our research resulted in the knowledge that there is literally no place you can live in the USA where some sort of Ag Program isn’t going on. Whether it’s so-called ‘invasive’ insects, or industrial farming, pesticides and herbicides are being dumped across the land year-round.
Short of moving to a small island of our own somewhere (I wish!), we determined that all we could do is stand and fight, right where we are. Protecting ourselves from poisoning doesn’t seem possible, but fighting to change the world we live in is definitely possible, and it is happening around the globe…in Mexico, Canada, South America, Australia, Europe. I believe we can make change happen, but I also know that I am being exposed to toxins every day while America continues to be chemical-dependent. I wish there was a safe place to be, but we could not find one.
I am so wishing you protection, health and peace, Donna.
Mim
Hi Solstice,
Isn’t that the truth! I’m impressed by your discernment of this situation. Marketing can sell almost anything to anybody, sadly, and the power of simply putting a shiny name on something has managed to convert the barren industrial alcohol factories into the romantic ‘Wine Country’.
Fortunately, with research, people like yourself can learn to see past the marketing slogans to the truth of millions of Californian’s being sickened and killed by the pesticide/herbicide use that makes monoculture possible. And, you can share that truth with everyone you care about. That’s a powerful fact!
Thanks for taking the time to comment, Solstice. It’s always a pleasure to see you here.
Mim
This blog entry totally mischaracterizes the Sonoma Co. Bd. of Supe’s letter. In that letter the board requests that environmental review be completed so that TWIST TIES can be placed in areas where the moth has been found. They are not requesting pheromone sprays! It is the writers of this blog entry and the creators of the propagandistic posters on this page who are responding hysterically. Why you use this opportunity to slam California Certified Organic Farmers makes no sense, either. There is nothing in the stakeholders’ document that endorses spraying. In fact, they specifically state that they support ground treatments with pheromone twist ties, NOT SPRAYING. Pheromone twist ties are a useful, non-toxic way to control pests that damage crops, long used in certified organic orchards. The stakeholders also support other biological controls including sterile insect release, parasitic wasp release, and foliar ground treatments and male moth attractants *using organically approved pesticides.*
Welcome to VeganReader, Sane Jane,
I am sorry, but you have been misinformed by someone about the toxicity of the twist ties. They are, in fact, quite toxic and I have now heard from multiple people who have fallen extremely ill after being near them. Please, do some further research on this and do not accept CDFA’s assurances that the toxic substances they promote are safe. Please, if you are interested, visit this page and scroll down to the information about twist ties and the other poisonous substances being suggested by CDFA and the alcohol industry:
http://www.dontspraycalifornia.org/lbam.html
At VeganReader, we maintain a strict zero toxins policy. We don’t use chemicals on our farm. True organic farming practices do not require sprays of any kind, whether they are organic-approved or not. Nature keeps the balance when man understands the right role to play in the garden, but the groups and methods you are choosing to defend and champion have very different views about this.
The bottom line, however, is that twist ties are definitely toxic, and if you’ve been misinformed by industry sources regarding this, perhaps it’s time for you to question how much of your information is correct. Fortunately, the Internet makes it very easy for concerned citizens to seek disinterested truths rather than party line propaganda. I hope you will keep researching this issue, Sane Jane. It’s a critical one.
Mim
In reply to Donna’s question about the season of spraying in Sonoma, and also Sane Jane’s misstatement that LBAM twist ties are nontoxic. First, about spray season in Sonoma: it depends on the growers near you. In Carneros, where we lived until I got my kids out, it was up to 11 months of the year. Growers start the herbicide treadmill by December 1st, or as soon as they see a blade or leaf of anything green that isn’t a vine. They add insecticides at various points and certainly those are everywhere by summer months, and fungicides are everpresent especially once the vines show any fruit. Greedy modern agribusiness growers have “taught” all the newbies that brought their money in from the DotCom boom to grow the cash crop all over the state. They have taught the new, chemical-laden ways which are based on trying to wring as much alcohol as possible out of each acre, even if they are killing the soil in the process. Part of that way is planting vines closer than they ever had been planted in history. What does this do? Crowds everything so that fungus is a given. What is done about that? Fungicides. Rodenticides are used any time of the year.
Are people sickened by fungicides? Oh, yeah. Insecticides? Certainly? Herbicides? Ever heard of Hormonal Disruption? Metabolic disturbances? Everywhere in Wine Country, along with rampant cancers, respiratory problems, neurological problems and the list goes on and on and on. My old obits files from Sonoma point to one thing abundantly clearly: If you live in Sonoma, your life expectancy is slashed dramatically. So many kids with cancers, many dead. So many in their 20′s, so many in their 30′s, so many in their 40′s. Notice all the people limping around Sonoma? Neurotoxins are wiping out the quality of life for many while carcinogens are straight out killing people.
This is a case of the truth being worse than any fiction we could create. An epidemiological study must be done of Sonoma and Napa but the fact is that no public agency which should be arranging this has, or ever has been willing to demand it of the state or feds. That’s fact.
Now, about LBAM twist ties. These not only are not nontoxic, they are very toxic. Rather than rehash is less useful detail, I will point you to our LBAM page on our website: http://www.DontSprayCalifornia.org. On the right side of the home page you can click on the LBAM page. To the right of that page, click on the section about the harmful effects of the pesticides part of that program. The same pesticide as in the aerial pesticide which made actually tens of thousands sick (based on a prof. of Systems Management and Statistics) is in the twist ties AND in the white tent-like LBAM traps. Many of us have been sickened by exposure to those already. Please do not believe the hype thrown out by the government. Take a look at our site for facts facts facts. More than you might want to know, but I urge you to take the thousands of hours of work assembling this information and use it to avoid reinventing the wheel. You don’t even have to do a lot of research yourself if you just read down the LBAM page and click on whatever document interests you to see the source materials.
I have not recovered from exposure to the twist ties at a hearing on the subject held in Sonoma in July of ’08. It is scary. I see an opthamologist tomorrow because I have had eye problems since then, and my blood sugar has remained dangerously high since then, even with whatever supportive health care I have been able to access (far less than I need after that).
I appreciate that you might want to believe people we SHOULD be able to trust. I mean, tax money is put into funding these massive bureaucracies… what’s going on here? THIS subject is one where you might want to put in some more research time. All we can tell you is the facts show LBAM is NOT a problem, nor is it expected to be (check out the entomologists’ statements) but the pesticides (including in the traps and twist ties) are a clear and present danger.
Poisoning people, pets, wildlife, the environment is off the table for discussion. None must occur.
mim,
all i can say is i’ve been sprayed with checkmate and i decided when i had to move, if the lbam program was still not over i would leave california. i have never recovered it from it fully. i am going to taos where the air is clean, the rents are cheap compared to here and i can stop living in limbo. i’m just afraid to set up a new home and have to flee if the cdfa has it’s way again. i am scared, sad (this is breaking up my family) and excited.
thank you for your continued hard work. now that i am waking up i saw a cal trans truck spraying a busy road here and i was horrified to be anywhere near it.
donna
sane jane,
the sonoma county board of supervisors is backing a lot more than twist ties which are toxic. other than disagreement over spraying “rural” areas they back various toxic ground treatments such as permethrin. for those of sickened by checkmate which has now been pulled off the market we do not wish to be experimented on again.
Hi Donna,
Oh, of all the wonderful places to move, Taos sounds like a beautiful one to me. You will be moving into sacred territory. My husband’s Comanche people hail from New Mexico and some of mine were from just over the border. There are some very sacred places in New Mexico that I hope you can learn about as you settle in there.
You deserve peace and a good long rest, Donna. These have been terrible times for you. Please, don’t lose touch with us here. We will want to know that you are okay, wherever you are.
Mim
thank you, mim
i hope u and your family stay healthy and happy where you are. it is a dream of mine to live there, i just find it an absurd way to get there! will certainly stay in touch.
donna
Leave A Reply