My parents often say, “if only Carter were still president.” No other U.S. president made such valiant efforts to begin converting our country to alternative energy, and unfortunately, so many of his good plans were abandoned once his presidency ended. If Carter were in office now, I have no doubt we’d all be living in solar powered homes and driving planet-friendly cars.
This evening, I visited the website of The Carter Center and their mission statement brought tears to my eyes: advancing human rights and alleviating unnecessary human suffering. Join us in creating a world in which every man, woman, and child has the opportunity to enjoy good health and live in peace. To a Californian, living under the threat of chemical assault by my government, these sound like words from heaven. I was inspired to write to Mr. and Mrs. Carter, and I want to share my letter with you.
——
Dear Mr. & Mrs Carter,
I was only a young girl when you were President and First Lady of the United States, but my parents have always spoken with great respect for the environmental efforts you made during that period.
I am writing to you this evening because I am so moved by the mission statement of the Carter Center: Creating a world in which every man, woman, and child has the opportunity to enjoy good health and live in peace.
I am very sorry if the following information is difficult and upsetting to read, but it is true, and I am certain you will both want to know about it.
The health and peace of the people of California is being egregiously threatened by the actions of three parties: Gov. Schwarzenegger, the California Deparment of Food and Agriculture and the pesticide manufacturer, Suterra LLC. These three parties have joined forces in a plan to subject some 7 million Californians to aerial spraying of a pesticide compound which contains documented carcinogens, mutagens, endocrine disruptors, breast-cancer-causing xenochemicals and synthetic pheromone mimics. This compound is encapsulated in microscopic spheres which are classified by the American Lung Association as small enough to be deemed particulate pollution – they enter the deep lung and cannot be expelled.
The spraying began in the fall of 2007 in Monterey and Santa Cruz counties. Hundreds of families were sickened and their symptoms matched, point for point, the known effects of the disclosed ingredients of the spray compound, Checkmate. These counties desperately tried to halt the spraying, but the state has declared an emergency which has allowed them to bypass all safeguards which are in place to protect human and environmental health. There has been no EIR done or anything that would normally occur to protect Americans from harm. The compound has never been tested on human beings – it has only been sprayed on crops. CDFA’s target – the Light Brown Apple Moth – has done zero damage to California agriculture, native plants or ornamentals and is considered an unimportant bug elsewhere in the world. However, because this bug was originally incorrectly classified as a Class A pest, trade restrictions apply to farmers where the moth lives. Because of this, CDFA and the USDA are being funded by Homeland Security to aerially spray 9 counties in the state, including the densely populated SF Bay Area. Never before has urban spraying of this kind been done in our nation, and we have been coldly informed that we have no vote in the matter.
Senators, representatives, civic governments, superintendents, town mayors and the people of California have come out in adamant opposition to the aerial spraying of human beings. UC Scientists and doctors are trying to rush to our aid with facts which prove both that the moth does no real damage and that the pesticide will do tremendous damage to us. Unfortunately, our governor has received tremendous documented donations from both the Ag. Secretary and the spray manufacturer and he is being accused of grave corruption by local government officials.
My loved ones, friends and neighbors are living in terror of their own public servants, and residents are becoming refugees in an attempt to flee to safety before the spraying recommences June 1, 2008. We will be sprayed 3-5 nights a month, from 8 PM – 5 AM, every 30 days, 9 months a year for up to ten years or more. The chronic pesticide exposure this will create is, frankly, terrifying, and because the pesticide is manufactured to remain in the environment for 30-90 days, there will never be an all-clear. There will never be a day with fresh air again in California if the spraying is not halted.
In addition to the serious health harm to humans caused by the 2007 spraying, it is important to add that at least 600 sea birds died in Monterey Bay, washing up in a thick scum of yellow foam which covered the ocean and watershed. Pets died. Songbirds stopped singing. Beekeepers reported that their honeybees became disoriented, struggling on the ground before dying. The microcapsules are deadly to our endangered honeybees and their contents are poisonous to aquatic life.
The labels of the ingredients in Checkmate sternly warn that they must be kept away from children, not inhaled, not put on skin, not introduced into water. But CDFA is putting them on our children, in our lungs, on our skin, in our watershed. And everyone who is benefiting monetarily and professionally from the spray keeps telling us it is safe to do exactly what the labels warn you not to do.
The health and environmental damage, damage to tourism and the economy that will be caused by the spray are considerable, and each subject is being tackled by professionals concerned with each of these things – doctors, scientists, naturalists, business owners. But no matter what evidence, what research, what proof and documentation of damage we present, we are dismissed by the Governor and Ag. Secretary A.G. Kawamura. In violation of the California Constitution which guarantees our right to obtain safety and the Nuremberg Code which declares that human beings will never again be experimented upon without their consent, we are being told we have no rights, no choice. We are living in severe civil unrest with no peace and no prospects for a healthy future here in California.
I know that your foundation works all over the world to protect the rights of human beings and to help them obtain peace and safety. I am writing to implore you to investigate what is being done to us in California and to consider speaking against the aerial spraying of urban populations. It is our belief that California is the testing ground, and if agencies are allowed to spray here, it will become a new national policy to spray pesticides on human beings. We can hardly stand to think of our beloved nation going this way.
Please, hear our voices. We are desperately begging for help as we try to defend our dear ones from chemical assault. Please, take a moment to visit some of the following resources to learn about what is being done to Californians:
Here is an informative town hall meeting video from Berkeley:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=4Rlf9vns1uE
Here is an interview with Michael Lynberg, a private citizen who began documenting the pesticide illnesses:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=n7Q6pmLX3po
Here is a CBS news video on the spraying:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=1uzxyhnLuyE
You can watch many other videos about this public health crisis here:
http://youtube.com/user/LBAMspray
Here is a document compiled by the Environment and Human Rights Advisory listing 23 Human Rights Violations the spray presents:
http://www.lbamspray.com/00_Documents/2008/EHRA.pdf
Here is a web page documenting the known health damages caused by the ingredients in the spray:
http://hopefortruth.com/
Here is a report compiled by two respected UC scientists documenting the Light Brown Apple Moth in New Zealand and its negligible effects:
http://lbamspray.com/00_Documents/2008/HarderNZReportFINAL.pdf
Here are several websites that are covering the anti-spray people’s movement:
http://www.lbamspray.com
http://www.cassonline.org
http://www.stopthespray.org
California remembers DDT. Our veterans remember Agent Orange. We are so insulted to hear officials telling us that exposing humans to pesticides is safe and acceptable for us. They have told us we need to ‘tolerate it’, but we believe that human health should always take precedence over the financial concerns of special interests groups, and I believe that you would agree with that, Mr. and Mrs. Carter. Please, I am imploring you to research this. Time is running out for us and only public outcry and pressure on our governor will stop the disaster before any further damage is caused to our air, water, land and people. Please, consider speaking out against this spray and asking Governor Schwarzenegger to cancel his plan of spraying untested chemical compounds on human beings.
I sincerely thank you for your time and consideration and am praying that you will be able to answer my letter.
Kind Regards,
& etc.
——
I urge my readers to please consider contacting the Carter Center.
Mailing Address:
The Carter Center
One Copenhill
453 Freedom Parkway
Atlanta, GA 30307
Phone:
(404) 420-5100 or (800) 550-3560
E-mail:
carterweb@emory.edu
Please, ask Mr. & Mrs. Carter to send a message to the governor asking him to stop the spray.



6 users commented in " My LBAM Spray Letter to Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackThat was a moving letter, Mim. Thank you. Also, I was in tears reading about little Jack Wilcox. I can’t imagine the frustration his parents must feel.
ABC 7 wrote a better article after I challenged them and told them to check out CBS 5′s article from 5/15.
Roy Upton’s video was really informative.
Lots of work to do!
Mary Anne
in addition to sickening people and animals, it seems to me that this spray will make all food from califoria inedible, and that organic food will no longer be organic,even if they figure out a way to tell us that it is. i do not live in california any longer, but i still eat food grown there, until june, after which i will refuse anything grown in that state.
i have noticed, however, that they are planning to find this moth everywhere, so that all of us can get sprayed, so i am doing all i can to inform as many as possible, including a call to Mr Carter’s office.
Mary Ann,
You are so smart to be writing to the news reporters. Keep up the wonderful work on that!
Mim
Solstice-
Yes, the organic industry will be utterly demolished by this. It is very disturbing that USDA has told the organic farmers that they can still keep their organic status, even after pesticides have been poured on their crops. It’s ridiculous. I have been eating organic for more than 15 years, and to me, organic means ‘no pesticides’.
It is my belief that one of the most saving things families can do if they are able to move away from the spraying will be to start growing their own vegetables. Up until the 1980s, it was very common for people to grow at least some of their own produce. Then people started putting in lawns or swimming pools on their property instead – such a waste when you think that space could feed your family and, these days, cut your grocery bill in half.
This is one of the things about the spraying that is most heartbreaking to me. My husband and I had a dream of becoming organic farmers one day. But, if they spray, we cannot do this here. That makes me feel so upset and hopeless, and we know we will have to move if the spraying isn’t stopped and we want to grow our own food. Few businesses have damaged our planet the way Agribusiness has, and we can take the power away from them if we grow our own food…but how can we do that in California if the ground, air and water is poisoned?
You are among many, Solstice, who will refuse to buy California produce. Would you please consider contacting CCOF and telling them this? They are against the spraying, but they need to hear from people that fighting the spraying is what they must do if they want a market outside the state for their crops.
Thank you for taking the time to comment. Please, come back again.
Mim
thanks for the reminder and the welcome. i contacted CCOF, which makes reference to ‘foodsyou can trust”. i think they should live up to that motto then.
i had planned to start my own veg garden, and have several rodale books, etc.., to study how to do it correctly. unfortunately, i may have to begin by doing it incorrectly, due to the urgency i am now presented with.
meanwhile, i am contacting everyone who has anything to do with food buying, as i want them to know that no one will want california produce or other food if this diabolical plan goes ahead.
and i am adding prayer, for all people and animals in california, and for myself and my own place, as i assume the sprayers will try it out here as well if your state is attacked.
Great letter. One thing I’ll add–the numbers of potentially affected people from pending spray are tens of millions. Tourists flock to California. I only learned of Monterey and Santa Cruz spray because I was a tourist who learned after my visit about the spray, which likely is why I experienced disturbing health impacts. Should spray go through–we must stop it!–we’ll have to warn the world not to come to spray areas in N. California for several years.
Leave A Reply