Who Are The Heroes in the LBAM Spray War?

I want to take a moment to sing heartfelt praises for some of those individuals I have seen taking heroic action over the past 8 months in the public health crisis that the California Department of Food and Agriculture has created with their aerial spraying of the Light Brown Apple Moth. These are the faces that appear again and again on the YouTube videos, the voices on the radio, the minds behind some of the most brilliant documents and articles created in the midst of our calamity. I know that not one of these men or women are giving of themselves so fully with any thought to public praise, but they deserve it, nonetheless.

Maxina Ventura of East Bay Pesticide Alert
Maxina has been working for pesticide reform since the 90s. She began to educate herself when her family began falling ill living in the polluted Sonoma County Wine Country. Maxina and her children lost their health and discovered multiple cancer clusters rooted in the neighborhoods that are sandwiched between the ag wasteland that has been created by alcohol growers. She was a leader in achieving protection for public health in the Glassy-winged Sharpshooter campaign and is now spending countless hours of her time attending and holding conferences, and making radio appearances regarding LBAM.

Maxina’s proposals for pesticide reform are the most thorough, sound and far-reaching you will encounter anywhere in this crisis. Zero tolerance for pesticide exposure is the platform she is urging people to support. It’s not just the aerial spraying. It’s the traps, the twist ties, the permethrin-coated trees and telephone poles that will poison us and our dear ones. No other person I have spoken to in this situation has a better hands-on education about the true risks of pesticide poisoning, its short and long-term health effects.

Mayor Robert Lieber of Albany
You can ask my husband - when I first read Mayor Lieber’s forthright public letter confronting the truth of the abuse of the people of California and calling for the immediate resignation of Ag. Sec. A.G. Kawamura if the spraying wasn’t halted - I stood up and shouted for joy!

What is it that keeps so many civic leaders silent? Fear of professional punishment…they’ll be snubbed at the next gala dinner, out of the running for a posh new position, maybe fired. That is why we must praise our public servants when they go with their ethics in opposition to the corruption which is so baldly evident now in our state. I have had the pleasure of hearing Mayor Lieber speak several times now, and his insistence that the health of his town is worth more than trade profits is like a breath of fresh air in the rotten environment of California politics.

Michael Lynberg and HOPE
Thanks to Michael, we have the documents of the hundreds of reported pesticide-induced illnesses from 2007 in the Monterey/Santa Cruz region. Good Samaritin ethics have since impelled Mike not only to speak at conferences and hearings, but really, to become one of the most eloquent and humane voices in this whole fiasco. When Michael says our health is important, it astonishes me that ‘officials’ don’t just automatically agree with the obvious reason of his statement.

Like so many of the good people who have stepped forward in this crisis, Michal’s family was sickened by the spray - a major violation of his family’s right to safety. The actions of CDFA are further infringing on Michael’s private life by calling him away from his already-busy schedule as a writer in Silicon Valley in order to make public and radio appearances and do interviews. He doesn’t have any more free time than the rest of us do, and he is making this sacrifice of his private time and life in order to keep working to protect all of us. It is a pleasure to listen to him whenever he speaks.

Nan Wishner, Chairperson of the Albany Integrated Pest Management Task Force
When I hear Ms. Wishner speak, it’s a relief to my soul - listening to her voice of reason. I first experienced this sensation when I watched her tell a packed-house in Marin that we could not trust the Ag. Department this time around. Her concern for short and long-term human health is so evident and she does such a good job of narrowing information down to the essential snippets that stick in people’s minds - that’s a talent! She has been at so many of the meetings and, like the others on my list, is making a praiseworthy sacrifice of her private time in order to defend public health.

John Russo of Stop The Spray
We may all think of him as that man in the hat but John Russo is striking us as a super-powered individual. He has made so many personal appearances at civic and governmental meetings, you’d begin to suspect he’s learned how to be in two places at once! StoptheSpray.org is responsible for the petition to stop the spray which I expect to see reaching 20,000 signatures soon. John’s energy and dedication to defending our health are incredibly meritorious. He has been through the horrors of the 2007 spraying, and if there is any justice left in the world, the organizational and feet-on-the-street work that John and his friends at StoptheSpray.org are so tirelessly undertaking will prevent the people of the Central Coast region from being poisoned again.

Roy Upton
Roy Upton’s journey on the LBAM path began when he discovered more than a score of dead Cormorants the day after the first 2007 spraying. An herbalist by trade, Roy has gone on to create crucial documents such as this one on the health damages caused by permethrin. You can hear Roy’s heartfelt concern about the poisoning of wildlife and water when he speaks, and like the others on this list, he is giving freely of his time to attend meetings, speak on the radio and give interviews. Roy is a concerned citizen, just like you and me, and the care and grounded reasoning he brings into this situation are so vital.

Dr. Daniel Harder
UCSC Arboretum director and botanist, Daniel Harder, has given a kind of credibility to our protest against this violation of human rights that we could only receive from a scientist. When Dr. Harder insists, point blank, that the moth is not a problem and that the eradication efforts are doomed to fail, you are hearing his years of professional study behind every syllable. As Dr. Harder has mentioned on the radio and in several of the numerous legal and civic meetings he has attended, the majority of his colleagues agree that the ‘voracious moth’ is a complete myth, but as he says, these men are afraid to speak up. Doubtless, fear of professional punishment is making them choose personal comfort over public safety, and this is all the more reason why Dr. Harder’s brave and informed stance is so commendable. I also want to praise Jeff Rosendale for his work in New Zealand which made it possible for us to ascertain that this moth is a negligible insect.

Senator Carol Migden
So far as I understand, it is only Sen. Migden’s measure requesting a moratorium on the aerial spraying that has the potential to be acted upon quickly enough to protect the public before the bombardment begins this summer. The senator has a long history of standing up for environmental protection, and I want to praise her for attempting to defend us from the government and its agencies. These are dark days in which to be a politician.

Many, many more individuals belong on our list. The city council members, representatives and senators who have asked the tough questions, trying to pin down the slippery A.G. Kawamura and his cohorts. The members of CASSonline.org and LBAMspray.com who are working so tirelessly in this effort. The doctors and nurses who have stepped forward to declare that the actions of the government threaten public health. And all of the un-named individuals who are devoting hours every day to educating their communities about the jeopardy in which we are all being held.

I know that, like me, every one of you has a job, daily duties, a family to care for, so much of the business of life that demands your time and attention every day. But as I have heard from countless people now, understanding what the spraying will do to us and our home has a way of taking precedence in the lives of people who are frankly, already very busy. We want to win this fight against corruption and abuse. We all want to get back to the day when we feel reasonably confident that we can take a walk tomorrow, drink our cup of tea, prepare food for our dear ones, make plans for our futures without this terrifying threat of chemical assault being held over our heads by CDFA.

If you want to see this day come, if you want to find a road back to reasonable peace but you have yet to make your voice heard in this crisis, please, join us. It isn’t enough to let others protect you. You need to start acting today to protect your own life. You have talents and I believe you will find the time, somehow, to demand a halt to the spraying now so that there is a more hopeful tomorrow for all of us.

Know Someone Who Should Be On This List? Please Feel Free To Mention Them In the Comments

9 Responses to “Who Are The Heroes in the LBAM Spray War?”

  1. on 11 Apr 2008 at 3:20 am bpm4327

    There are so many heroes in the LBAM Spray War.

    The first goes to all the people in the Santa Cruz and Monterey Counties. All of them have been impacted the most by this horrendous war. Unfortunately and sadly they were the canaries in the mine and they warned us about all the health and environmental consequences that happened to them and their environment. Out of their sorrows they have given us the truth about the LBAM Project. Additionally, many of them became activists for their own survival and that of their families and also of the Central Coast and beyond. Because of all of these things they are the truest of true heroes.

    Let us not forget all the other heroes:
    Paul Schramski, California Director, Pesticide Watch - he has tirelessly helped this fight for all of us;
    Dr. James Carey, UC Davis, Entomologist. Dr. Carey has brought a well-respected scientific voice that told us that LBAM is wide spread and has probably been here for 40+ years, is well established, and there would be a zero probability of eradicating LBAM; Jeff Rosendale, Horticulture Consultant in Watsonville, published reports along with Dr. Daniel Harder, UC Santa Cruz; California Senator Joe Simitian who worked with California Senator Carol Migden to present a panel of experts to the public to inform us about LBAM; California Assembly members who drafted and have pending LBAM related legislation coming before the Agriculture Committee on April 16 - those members are: Loni Hancock, John Laird, Mark Leno, Jared Huffman, andSandre Swanson; all the organizations that have publicly opposed the LBAM Project; all the people who have taken their time to attend meetings and speak on others’ behalves, as well as, their own; all City and County elected officials who have and continue to oppose the LBAM Project for the safety and well-being of their communities; all County Public Health Officials who have actively spoken at meetings and who have written letters opposing the LBAM Project; all website administrators who have devoted their time to keep all of us informed on every move and action every minute of the day so all of us can be educated and involved in order to stand up for ourselves and others opposing the LBAM Project: veganreader.com, stopthespray.org, California Alliance to Stop the Spray, Hope for Truth, lbamspray.com, North Coast Rivers Alliance (also a special thank you Frank Egger, Sandra Ross, and to Keith Andrews); and a very special thank you to environmental attorney Stephen Volker who will seek truth and justice for the environment and all living things.

  2. on 11 Apr 2008 at 11:17 am Repulsed

    I think to have such a post is rather insulting to the many dedicated individuals that have been in this movement for many months before some on your list were even aware of what was going on. Posts like this do nothing to make people feel good. It only creates feelings of exclusion.

    There are many, many, many heros in this movement, including every dedicated individual that have ALREADY been sprayed and have worked tirelessly to stop the next round of spraying for everyone, including for those in the Bay Area that have just recently found out about the issue. The previous person commenting tried to list many key individuals but has still excluded countless people.

    I really think that this posting is a slap in the face and does nothing to further the movement or encourage those that have given every hour of their day to this movement, which aren’t mentioned here. It’s disappointing to see this posting on your website. Please reconsider it’s inclusion on your site.

  3. on 11 Apr 2008 at 12:50 pm admin

    Dear Repulsed,

    We’re a bit confused that this article strikes you as exclusive. Please, re-read the following paragraph, as we think it will change your mind:

    “Many, many more individuals belong on our list. The city council members, representatives and senators who have asked the tough questions, trying to pin down the slippery A.G. Kawamura and his cohorts. The members of CASSonline.org and LBAMspray.com who are working so tirelessly in this effort. The doctors and nurses who have stepped forward to declare that the actions of the government threaten public health. And all of the un-named individuals who are devoting hours every day to educating their communities about the jeopardy in which we are all being held.”

    I’m unsure of you cause for complaint, and if there are folks you’d like to see honored here, this is your opportunity to praise and thank them, as this part of the above article indicates:

    “Know Someone Who Should Be On This List? Please Feel Free To Mention Them In the Comments”

    I appreciate you taking the time to share your feelings on this, but your comment has an awfully negative tone in light of the fact that we wrote this to thank everyone for all of the hard work they are doing.

    We realize this is your first comment here at Vegan Reader, and hope you will be better pleased by some of our other and future offerings. Like everyone else in this crisis, we are voluntarily doing what we are doing, in any free time we can find, in hopes of being of service to the community.

    We hope you’ll reconsider the passages of the article we’ve copied here, and see if they appear exclusive in nature upon reading them carefully a second time.

    Thanks.
    Mim

  4. on 11 Apr 2008 at 12:55 pm admin

    Thank you, BPM, for adding to this thank you list! I agree, all of the folks you mentioned deserve our heartfelt gratitude.

    You know what I’d like to do? Get a phone book for each of the 9 spray counties and send them in a bundle to Governor Schwarzenegger with a note: “These are all of the people the spraying will harm.” It would be quite a big package!

  5. on 15 Apr 2008 at 7:37 pm isabelle

    I would like to add to this list Helen from Care2, the site that powers the petition on http://www.stopthespray.org

    She has been amazing, using her connections to generate awareness and support. But today she outdid herself: she turned each of the 20,000 + signatures and petition comments into a fax and sent them off to some particularly hard hearted Assemblymembers… after a few hundred faxes the machines were jammed or turned off and Helen was called by angry aides and asked to please stop! But Helen said: Each one of these faxes represents a person that needs to heard! Go Helen.

  6. on 15 Apr 2008 at 7:57 pm admin

    Oh, my goodness! Way to go Helen! That’s a wonderful anecdote, Isabelle. I can just imagine the fax machines going full tilt.

    I celebrate Helen with you!
    Mim

  7. on 21 Apr 2008 at 3:07 pm Beverly Giraudo

    Joanie Greggains is devoting one hour of her radio program each Saturday to this issue. She has spoken to the S.F. Board of Supervisors, the Sausalito town Council, and has been to Sacramento two times.
    She has appeared on KGO programs with Ronn Owens, Korel and Christine Craft in an attempt to spread the word. A letter has gone out to every associate and friend describing her great concern.

  8. on 21 Apr 2008 at 3:21 pm admin

    Beverly - what an excellent addition to this post. Joanie and her producer, Cindy, are doing such valiant work to speak and educate. I have gotten to speak with both of them and they are such intelligent, caring people. They absolutely deserve our heartfelt thanks and praise for their incredible forthrightness.

    Thank you for taking the time to mention them here! Please, come back again soon, and feel free to add anyone else you can think of to this ‘thank you note’ post.
    Mim

  9. on 21 Apr 2008 at 3:26 pm admin

    I want to add a few more names.

    Thank you to Dr. Larry Rose and Dr. Richard Philp for publishing their crucial analyses of the dangerous toxicity of the ingredients in LBAM spray. These good and abundantly qualified doctors take their professional responsibility of protecting public health very seriously!

    Thank you to Foster Gamble and CASSonline.org for amassing the amazing data on the BILLIONS of dollars of economic damage aerial spraying will inflict on the real estate, tourism and organic farming industries in California. This was wonderful work!

    Please, everybody, keep on adding your personal thank yous to all these friends and neighbors who are working at our side to stop the spray.

Trackback this Post | Feed on comments to this Post

Leave a Reply